Old wood windows are built to be repaired
A traditional wood window is a simple system: a wood sash, a pane of glass and the putty that seals them together, protected by paint. The sash is held together with mortise-and-tenon joints rather than glue, so a single rotted rail or a broken muntin can be repaired or replaced without replacing the whole window. Many old sashes were also made from slow-grown, dense wood that holds up well when the paint and putty are kept up.
That matters in Columbus’s older neighborhoods, including historic districts such as German Village and Victorian Village, where keeping original wood windows working is often the first thing to try.
Where wood windows fail
National Park Service guidance notes that deterioration in poorly maintained windows usually begins on horizontal surfaces and at joints, where water collects and soaks into the wood. Peeling paint is often the first sign of where. Damp summers and winter days that thaw by afternoon and freeze again overnight give that water plenty of chances to do damage. Look first at:
- The sill, especially its outer edge and the ends where it meets the frame
- The bottom rail of each sash
- Joints at the corners of the sash
- Glazing putty that has cracked, shrunk or fallen out
- Paint that has peeled down to bare gray wood
The repairs, from routine to structural
Freeing painted-shut sashes
Layers of paint across the gap between sash and stop are the most common reason old windows don’t open. Careful cutting of the paint film, and sometimes removing and resetting the stops, gets them moving again.
Reglazing
Failed putty is removed, the wood is primed and the glass is reset with new glazing points and putty, then painted to seal the joint.
Cords and weights
Replacing broken sash cords with new rope or chain is one of the most common jobs on an old window. The weight pocket is usually opened through a small door near the bottom of the frame, and the original weights and pulleys are reused. See sash and balance repair.
Consolidating and filling decay
Limited, localized rot can be stabilized with an epoxy consolidant that soaks into the decayed wood and hardens, then built back up with an epoxy patching compound that is sanded and painted.
Splices and new parts
When decay has gone too far for stabilization, the bad section is cut out and a new piece of wood is spliced in, or a whole rail, sill or stop is milled to match and replaced.
Weatherstripping and storm windows
The Park Service also notes that the energy performance of historic windows can be significantly improved without replacing them, by adding weatherstripping and storm windows.
When repair stops being practical
The National Park Service’s position on historic windows is that repair should be the first option considered, while recognizing that past a certain level of deterioration, repair stops being practical. A sash with one soft rail is a repair. A frame where the sill, jambs and most sash joints are rotted through is usually a candidate for replacement.
Historic districts and old paint
In Columbus’s historic districts, exterior changes to a building need a Certificate of Appropriateness, reviewed by the city’s Historic Preservation Office staff or the district’s commission. In German Village, the neighborhood society describes repair and reglazing as the preferred approach for historic windows, with replacement considered once office staff find that repair is no longer feasible. Contact the office before changing exterior window parts there.
Old window paint deserves care too. EPA says homes built before 1978 are more likely to have lead-based paint, and that painted surfaces that rub together, like windows and sills, can wear into chips and dust. Its renovation rule governs paid work that disturbs that paint. At home, EPA advises repairing small damaged areas without sanding; if sanding can’t be avoided, wet the area first, sand as little as possible and clean up thoroughly.
A fingertip inspection
- Press gently on sills and bottom rails with a fingertip; wood that feels spongy is a sign of decay.
- Look for gaps where putty has pulled away from the glass.
- Note which sashes are painted shut and which cords are broken.
To have old wood windows looked at, call or text (614) 333-6302 or book online.