Brick houses, brick streets and a commission that reviews the outside
German Village was settled by German immigrants in the early and middle 1800s, and its brick houses still line tree-shaded, brick-paved streets just south of downtown. Most of those houses have wood windows set into brick openings, and the size, shape and depth of those openings are the first thing a window change here has to respect.
The City of Columbus created the historic district and its German Village Commission in 1960. The commission issues Certificates of Appropriateness for exterior alterations under the district’s guidelines, and applications are filed with the city through its online Citizens Access Portal, not with the German Village Society.
What the review means for a window project
The German Village Society’s Certificate of Appropriateness FAQ puts it simply: a project that changes what the outside of the property looks like needs a certificate. Some categories of work, windows among them, can be approved by city preservation staff instead of waiting for a full hearing, and those staff approvals are then voted on by the commission at its next meeting. The city also keeps lists of approved window materials for the district, so ask for them before you shop.
A repair that leaves the window looking exactly as it did is the simplest path, but even then, a short call to the Historic Preservation Office before work starts is the safe move. Repair also covers most of what goes wrong with old windows here:
- Loose or cracked panes. New glass and fresh glazing putty in the old sash. See window glass replacement.
- A sash that won’t stay up or is painted shut. Broken cords, seized pulleys and paint-locked stops are repairable. See sash and balance repair.
- Soft wood on the bottom rail or sill. Rot can often be cut out and patched with matching wood. See wood window repair.
- Drafts around the sash. New weatherstrip and parting beads tighten an old window without changing how it looks from the street.
The National Park Service’s Preservation Brief 9, on repairing historic wooden windows, is the standard reference for this kind of work, and it is worth reading before you decide a window is beyond saving.
When a window does need replacing
Some sashes are too far gone, and some windows on a rear addition were never original. When replacement makes sense, the new unit should keep the size of the opening, the proportions of the sash and the muntin pattern, and sit back in the brick the way the old one did. A double-hung window built to the existing opening is the usual answer. We measure each opening, because old brick openings are rarely square or identical.
Lead paint in older homes
Nearly every house in the district predates 1978, so the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule comes into play when paid work disturbs painted sashes, stops or trim: the firm doing it must be certified and follow lead-safe work practices. Ask anyone you are thinking of hiring how they meet that rule.
What to gather before you apply
Whether the work ends up as a repair or a replacement, a review goes faster with good information. Before you contact the city, it helps to have:
- A photo of each window involved, inside and out, and a photo of the whole wall it sits in.
- A note of which windows face a street or alley, since those are the ones people see.
- A plain description of what is wrong with each window: rot, broken glass, a stuck sash, drafts.
- For a replacement, the product details and a drawing or profile of the new window next to the old one.
Getting started
A1 Windows works from 1221 Stimmel Rd, a short drive south of the district. A technician looks at the windows before we quote, and you see the price before any work starts. Call or text (614) 333-6302, or book online, and tell us whether you have already talked to the Historic Preservation Office. We can price a repair and a replacement side by side so you can take whichever the review favors.