Tall windows on big lots
When streetcar lines reached the land north of Goodale Park in the late 1800s, lots there were reserved almost entirely for large homes, and by 1920 most of them had filled in. The result is the mix you see along Neil Avenue today: Italianate, Queen Anne, Second Empire, Carpenter-Stick and foursquare houses, many with tall, narrow double-hung windows, bays and arched heads. Goodale Park itself, land Lincoln Goodale gave the city in 1851, is Columbus’s oldest planned park.
Windows on houses like these are big, heavy and often one of a kind. A replacement unit off a shelf rarely fits the opening or the look, which is one reason repair deserves a hard look first.
The Victorian Village Commission
The City of Columbus established Victorian Village as a historic district, with its own commission, in 1973. The commission issues Certificates of Appropriateness for exterior alterations under its district guidelines; the city’s preservation staff can tell you what a particular project needs. Window replacement on a street-facing wall is the kind of change the commission looks at, so talk to the city’s Historic Preservation Office before you sign for new windows.
Repairs that keep the original look
- Weight-and-pulley sashes that slam shut or won’t open: new cords, freed pulleys, cleaned-up stops. See sash and balance repair.
- Old wavy glass that has cracked: a single pane can be replaced and reglazed. See window glass replacement.
- Rotted sills and lower rails on the weather side: cut out and rebuilt in wood. See wood window repair.
- Sash locks and lifts that are missing or broken: see lock and hardware repair.
An interior or exterior storm window over a repaired sash is a long-standing way to cut drafts on old houses. An exterior storm window changes what the street sees, though, so include it in any conversation with preservation staff.
Rental units and lead paint
Some of the neighborhood’s big houses have been split into rented apartments. If you own one, note that the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule applies to paid work that disturbs paint in housing built before 1978, and the EPA says the rule does apply when you rent out all or part of your home. Old sashes, stops and casings are painted surfaces, so plan for lead-safe work on any window job and ask each contractor how they will handle it.
When replacement is the answer
On a rear wall, an addition, or a window that is past repair, a well-matched double-hung window made for the exact opening can work. We measure each opening on site, and we can price repair and replacement side by side so the choice is yours and the commission’s, not the catalog’s.
Before you talk to the commission
Commission staff can help most when you bring specifics. Know which windows you want to change and which walls they are on, take photos of each one inside and out, and find out whether the sashes are original. If you have had a repair assessment, bring it: showing why a window can or can’t be repaired is part of making the case for either choice.
Next step
A1 Windows is based at 1221 Stimmel Rd, Columbus. A technician looks at the windows before we quote, and you see the price before work starts. Call or text (614) 333-6302, or book online.