More than fifty styles, one recurring question
Olde Towne East is one of Columbus’s oldest neighborhoods, with more than a thousand homes, some dating to the 1830s, in a mix of more than fifty architectural styles. The land went from farmhouses to a subdivision in the 1870s, and growth along Broad, Long and Main streets and the arrival of the streetcar shaped the blocks you see now. After the Civil War, wealthy and working-class families lived within a few streets of each other, and the houses still run that whole range.
No single style means no single window. A Queen Anne with a turret, an Italianate with tall arched sashes and a foursquare with a broad front porch each need their own approach. What they share is age, and with age comes one recurring question: repair the original, or replace it?
Historic districts and the Historic Resources Commission
Parts of the neighborhood are inside districts on the Columbus Register of Historic Properties, among them the Bryden Road District and the 18th & E. Broad Historic District. On Columbus Register properties, exterior work needs a Certificate of Appropriateness. The city’s Historic Preservation Office guides owners through the application and reviews it before placing it on the agenda of the Historic Resources Commission, a mayor-appointed board. If you are not sure whether your address is in a district, the Historic Preservation Office can tell you.
What repair looks like on these houses
- Get the sash moving. Cut the paint seal, free the pulleys, re-hang the weights on new cords. See sash and balance repair.
- Fix the wood. Rot on sills and bottom rails can be cut out and rebuilt. See wood window repair.
- Re-glaze. Replace cracked panes and dried putty. See window glass replacement.
- Seal it. New weatherstrip, then a storm window if the house needs more comfort in winter.
Done in that order, each step makes the next one easier to judge: once a sash moves freely and its wood is sound, it is much clearer whether glazing and weatherstrip will bring it back or whether the window is truly past saving.
Houses that were apartments
By the 1950s, many of the larger, older homes here had been divided into apartments and rooming houses. In the 1970s a neighborhood association formed to preserve them, and many have since been brought back as single homes. A house that spent decades as apartments can be left with a mix of original sashes, mismatched later windows and openings that were changed. Sorting out which windows are original is the first job on a restoration, and it tells you where repair makes sense and where a matched replacement window might be approved.
Lead paint
A window that has been painted shut for decades has been painted many times, and in a house this old the bottom layers predate 1978. Cutting that seal is exactly the kind of paid work the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule covers: it calls for a certified firm using lead-safe practices, in rented units as well as owner-occupied homes.
Comfort without losing the originals
Big old windows can make an Olde Towne East house drafty, but replacing them is not the only way to warm it up. In order of cost:
- Make sure every sash closes fully and the sash lock pulls the meeting rails tight.
- Add or renew weatherstrip at the sides, meeting rail and bottom of the sash.
- Seal gaps between the casing and the wall.
- Add storm windows, after checking district rules.
Those steps keep the original glass, sash and trim that give these houses their character.
Talk to us
A1 Windows works from 1221 Stimmel Rd. A technician looks at the windows before we quote, and you see the price before work starts. Call or text (614) 333-6302, or book online, and mention whether your house is in a Columbus Register district.