Turn-of-the-century houses, fewer rules
Merion Village takes its name from the Merion family, who settled on 1,800 acres south of downtown Columbus in 1809; William and Sarah Merion made their home near what are now Moler and South High streets. Today the neighborhood runs from the Scioto River east to Parsons Avenue, with South High Street through its middle, and most of its homes were built around the turn of the 20th century. Many still have their original double-hung windows, and many others had them swapped out long ago.
One practical difference from its historic neighbor to the north: Merion Village is not one of the City of Columbus’s commission-reviewed historic districts, and the neighborhood is not a district on the Columbus Register of Historic Properties. That generally leaves window choices to you and your budget. Individual buildings can still be listed, so if you want to be certain about your own address, the city’s Historic Preservation Office can confirm it.
Freedom to choose, and a reason to choose carefully
Without a commission to satisfy, it can be tempting to treat every window as a quick swap. A few things are worth weighing first:
- Proportion. Turn-of-the-century houses use tall, narrow sashes. A replacement with a thick frame shrinks the glass and changes the face of the house.
- Repairability. A wood sash that is sound except for a broken cord or a cracked pane can be fixed for less than a new window. See sash and balance repair and window glass replacement.
- Where the money matters. Leaky, single-pane windows on the north and west walls may be worth replacing first, while the protected side waits.
Common jobs on these houses
- Painted-shut sashes and broken cords: balance repair.
- Rot at the sill and lower rail: wood window repair.
- Earlier replacement windows that now fog: foggy window repair.
- Torn screens or screens that no longer fit: screen repair.
- Whole-house upgrades: double-hung replacement windows sized to each opening, with energy-efficient glass.
Energy labels in plain terms
If you replace, read the label. The National Fenestration Rating Council label lists a window’s U-factor (lower means less heat lost through it) and its solar heat gain coefficient (lower means less of the sun’s heat comes through). ENERGY STAR sets different window criteria for different climate zones, and its online zone finder tells you which zone your home is in, so check that a product qualifies for your zone, not just somewhere.
Is the window original?
On houses this age, it is worth knowing which windows are original before deciding anything. Original wood sashes usually have putty holding the glass, weight pockets or pulleys in the side jambs, and many coats of paint. Later replacement units tend to have vinyl or aluminum jamb liners, insulated glass and tilt latches. Originals are often worth repairing; tired replacements are often the ones to replace first. A technician can sort them for you window by window during the visit.
Those many coats of paint on an original sash matter for another reason. On a house built around 1900, the oldest layers almost certainly predate 1978, and under the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule, paid work that disturbs them has to be done by a certified firm using lead-safe practices.
Nearby help
A1 Windows is at 1221 Stimmel Rd, a short drive away. A technician looks at the windows before we quote, and you see the price before work starts. Call or text (614) 333-6302, or book online.