Call nowCall (614) 333-6302

Columbus, OH · 55-mile service area

Homeowner guide · Wood window repair

Windows in Columbus Historic Districts: How Repair-First Works

Exploded 3D view of a double-hung window drawn out of a sided wall: frame, trim, upper and lower sashes with their glass, balances, sash lock, tilt latches, weatherstripping and screen
3D model

Old wood windows, with their slim muntins, wavy glass and painted sash, are a big part of what makes Columbus’s older neighborhoods look the way they do. If your house is in one of Columbus’s historic districts, changes to the outside of it, windows included, go through the city’s historic review process. The process favors keeping and repairing original windows, but it also has a clear path to replacement when repair is no longer practical.

This guide explains who reviews what, what the city’s staff can approve without a hearing, and how to plan window work so it goes smoothly. Rules and lists change, so treat it as orientation and confirm the specifics with the city’s historic preservation staff in the Planning Division before you start.

Who reviews window work

The City of Columbus has four historic review bodies, all staffed by the city’s Planning Division:

  • German Village Commission, for the German Village Historic District. See our German Village page.
  • Victorian Village Commission, for the Victorian Village district. See our Victorian Village page.
  • Italian Village Commission, for the Italian Village district.
  • Historic Resources Commission, which keeps the Columbus Register of Historic Properties and reviews exterior changes to individually listed properties and to Columbus Register districts, such as the Bryden Road district on the Near East Side. Since February 1, 2024, it has also covered the Brewery District.

These bodies issue a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) for exterior alterations. Whether your address falls inside a district is easy to check: the city’s board and commission pages link to a map where you can search an address.

Columbus also has design review bodies for other areas, such as the Downtown Commission and the University Impact District Review Board, with their own rules. Some suburbs with historic cores run their own architectural review as well, so check with your city if you live outside Columbus.

Wood window repair in Columbus, OH

Soft sills or rotting sashes? Repair what’s sound.

Call (614) 333-6302 Wood window repair details

What staff can approve without a hearing

Not every window project needs to go before a commission at a public meeting. The city publishes a Historic Common Staff Approval List of work that staff can generally approve when it is consistent with the city code and the district’s guidelines. You still file a COA application, but there is no hearing. For windows, the list includes:

  • Repair of historic windows.
  • Low-profile storm windows, with a brochure or manufacturer’s information.
  • Replacement of inappropriate, deteriorated or damaged windows using new windows from the city’s Approved Windows List, based on staff assessment with photo documentation and product information.
  • Restoration of original openings with appropriate new material, with drawings.

Under its general maintenance heading, the list also covers repairs that don’t replace historic material, or that replace it in kind when it is deteriorated beyond repair.

What “repair first” means in practice

Repair is the default. Look at how the staff list is worded: repair of historic windows is approvable on its own, while replacement is tied to windows that are inappropriate, deteriorated or damaged, and it rests on staff assessment backed by photos. In other words, the case for replacing an original window is built on its condition. When replacement is justified, the city’s Approved Windows List narrows the choice to products staff have already accepted, which spares you designing a window from scratch for review.

This lines up with the national standard. The National Park Service’s guidance on repairing wood windows rests on the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards, which call for repairing and retaining original materials and features wherever possible and, when necessary, replacing them in kind.

For a typical old double-hung window, “repair” can mean:

  • Freeing painted-shut sash and replacing broken sash cords (see why a window won’t stay open).
  • Reglazing with new putty and replacing cracked panes with matching glass.
  • Consolidating or patching decayed wood at sills and bottom rails, or splicing in new wood (see wood window rot: repair or replace).
  • Adding modern weatherstripping and sash locks to cut drafts.
  • Adding a low-profile exterior storm window for insulation and protection.

How to plan a window project in a district

  1. Confirm your district using the city’s address map.
  2. Document every window. For each one, note its location, the condition of the paint, frame and sill, sash, glass and hardware, and take clear photos inside and out. This is the evidence staff will look at, and it also gives you an honest picture of what you have.
  3. Get a repair assessment. Ask for a window-by-window description of what each needs, not just a single recommendation for the whole house.
  4. Talk to the city’s preservation staff early, especially if any replacement is on the table. Ask which guidelines apply to your district and what they want to see in the application.
  5. Apply online through the city’s Citizen Access Portal, with the photos, product information or drawings the staff list calls for.
  6. Wait for the COA before work starts, and keep a copy where the crew can see it.
  7. Phase sensibly. If the work will be spread over several years, finishing one whole façade at a time keeps each side of the house consistent instead of leaving a patchwork of old and new.

Lead paint is almost certain

Most houses in Columbus’s historic districts were built long before 1978, so old window paint should be presumed to contain lead until a test says otherwise. Under the EPA’s Renovation, Repair and Painting rule, a firm paid to disturb that paint must be certified and use lead-safe practices; small jobs under the rule’s minor-repair limits are exempt, but window replacement never qualifies for that exemption. Ask how dust will be contained and cleaned up.

Getting started

A1 Windows repairs and replaces windows across Columbus and communities within about 55 miles, and repair work on old wood windows is part of what we do. Our wood window repair page describes it in more detail. A technician goes window by window before quoting, so you have a scope of work you can share with preservation staff, and you see the price before any work starts. Call or text (614) 333-6302, or book online.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need approval to repaint my window trim in a historic district?

Exterior painting is on the city’s staff approval list, filed with paint chips or a color swatch and current photos. It is reviewed by staff rather than at a hearing, but it still goes through the application.

Do interior storm windows need approval?

Commission review covers exterior alterations. Interior storms generally aren’t visible as an exterior change, but confirm with the city’s preservation staff, and make sure interior storms seal well on the room side so they don’t trap moisture against the old sash.

Can I replace just the windows on the back of the house?

Commission review covers exterior alterations, and rear windows are on the exterior. Ask the city’s preservation staff how your district’s guidelines treat the rear of your property before you plan around it.

Are vinyl windows allowed in Columbus historic districts?

Replacement windows in the districts are expected to come from the city’s Approved Windows List or be approved through review. Check the current list with the city’s preservation staff before choosing a product.

Written by A1 Windows

A1 Windows replaces and repairs windows for homes in and around Columbus, Ohio. Questions about your windows? Call or text (614) 333-6302.

Call or text · Columbus, OH

Need wood window repair?

(614) 333-6302
  • You see the price before work starts
  • Columbus-based · 55-mile service area

More guides

All guides

Wood window repairNov 21, 2026 · 5 min read

Rotted Wood Windows: Repair, Rebuild or Replace?

Rot in a wood window almost always starts in the same few places, and it almost always comes from water that was allowed to sit. Finding how far it has gone is the first step toward deciding what to do.

Window replacementNov 21, 2026 · 5 min read

Vinyl, Fiberglass, Wood or Composite: Choosing a Window Frame

The glass gets most of the attention, but the frame decides how a window looks from the street, how much care it needs, and how well it holds its shape through decades of Ohio winters and summers.

Window replacementNov 21, 2026 · 5 min read

Pre-1978 Homes and Window Work: The EPA Lead-Safe Rules

If your home was built before 1978, paying someone to replace or repair its windows is regulated work. Windows are one of the places lead-based paint matters most, because sashes rub against painted frames every time they open and close.

Step 1 of 4

Book a window visit

What’s going on with your windows?

Pick the closest match to continue. You can add details on the next step.